Original strap or third-party? How to choose the right one for your smartwatch


By Bill WePack Marketing
5 min read

Original strap or third-party? How to choose the right one for your smartwatch

Both work, and the choice depends mainly on how you use your watch. Original straps are manufactured by the watchmaker and are designed specifically for your particular watch. Straps from third-party suppliers are manufactured by other companies and offer a wider range of materials, styles, and price points. Just like original straps, straps from third-party suppliers—unless they’re universal—are also made specifically for the watch. There are a few situations where only one type is recommended, and we’ll go over them below.

What is meant by “original” and “third-party”?

An original strap for the watch is manufactured or marketed by the watch’s manufacturer, such as Apple’s Sport Band or Garmin’s QuickFit straps. A third-party strap for the watch is manufactured by another company and is designed to fit the watch’s attachment mechanism.

Third-party straps are a broad category. It includes established manufacturers with their own quality control, specialized brands, and anonymous budget products. The difference between various third-party manufacturers is therefore often greater than the difference between an original strap and a high-quality third-party strap.

The advantages of original straps

  • Designed for your watch. The strap is developed by the same manufacturer as the watch and adheres to its specifications.
  • The manufacturer’s explicit support. Apple has developed the Ocean Band, Alpine Loop, and Trail Loop for the Apple Watch Ultra and rugged activities, and Garmin specifies which straps are compatible with the Fenix 9 Pro. There may therefore be some value in the same company that designed the watch also designing the strap that holds it in place, even though a strap isn’t quite as advanced a piece of technology.
  • Usually available at launch. When a new watch is released, the original straps are typically in stores right from the start, with matching colors and designs. Usually, at least one strap is included when you buy a new smartwatch.

Strengths of third-party straps

  • Wider selection. Milanese, nylon, FKM, leather, titanium, and silicone in many colors and patterns, often in styles that the watch manufacturers themselves don’t produce. This is beneficial for everything from style to comfort and for those with allergies.
  • A wider range of price points. Many third-party straps cost less than the originals, making it easier to own multiple straps and switch them out depending on the occasion: workouts, work, and evenings.
  • Specialization. Manufacturers that focus on straps often develop their own materials, clasps, and solutions for comfort and specific uses.
  • Split mounts. Apple’s slide mount, Garmin’s QuickFit and Quick Release, and Samsung’s Dynamic Lug are used by many manufacturers, so you can often keep the straps when you switch watches.
  • High-quality options are available. From an established manufacturer, a third-party strap can be fully comparable to the original in terms of materials and finish.

How to assess the quality of a third-party strap

Quality varies by manufacturer. Here’s what to check:

  1. Your exact model is specified. A strap that only specifies a width, or says “fits all,” provides a poorer fit than one made specifically for your model. Of course, there are many universal straps available, so broad compatibility isn’t necessarily an indication of poor quality.
  2. The material is specified. Good manufacturers specify the type of silicone or FKM, or the type of steel or titanium the strap is made of.
  3. The clasp is secure. There should be no play or creaking, and the clasp should close completely. An Apple Watch strap should slide on effortlessly and click into place, and a QuickFit clasp should close securely over the pin.
  4. The metal parts are durable. Buckles and clasps should not flake or discolor. Even original straps wear out with use, but that shouldn’t be the first thing to happen—regardless of where you bought your strap.

When the original is the safest choice

  • Garmin Fenix 9 Pro. Garmin’s manual states that metal straps, and straps with metal parts near the case, should not be used with the Fenix 9 Pro because they can interfere with GNSS, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and LTE and satellite functions. Garmin also advises avoiding third-party straps and using non-metallic Garmin straps (Garmin’s manual). For the Fenix 9 (non-Pro), there is no such warning in the manual.
  • Rugged water activities. For diving and similar activities, choose a strap that the manufacturer explicitly specifies for the activity, such as Apple’s Ocean Band for the Apple Watch Ultra. This applies regardless of whether the strap is original or third-party.

Quick guide: Which one should you choose?

Situation Recommendation 
Everyday use and work, with a desire for variety Third-party options offer the widest selection of materials and styles
Workouts Both work. Choose silicone or nylon with a secure clasp, and consider having a spare strap
Diving and rugged water activities A strap specified by the manufacturer for the activity
Sensitive skin Any material is fine, as long as it’s clearly specified
Spare straps Third-party straps are often a practical choice if you want multiple options

Find the right watch strap

No matter which one you choose: check the model, clasp, and width first. Start with the compatibility guide and the size guide. Read more about materials under Quality & Materials. The full selection is available under Apple Watch, Garmin, Samsung, and Fitbit.

Frequently asked questions

Are third-party straps as good as original straps?

It depends on the manufacturer. An established manufacturer can provide straps that are fully comparable to the originals in terms of materials and finish, while the quality of anonymous, low-cost products varies greatly. Use the checklist above.

Can a third-party strap damage the watch?

A strap that doesn’t fit exactly can wear down the watch’s attachment point. Choose straps that specify your model, and never force the strap on or off. Apple’s warranty does not cover damage caused by use with another product.

Can I use a third-party strap on the Garmin Fenix 9 Pro?

Garmin advises Pro owners to avoid third-party straps and metal straps and to use non-metallic Garmin straps instead. This is especially important if you rely on the satellite, LTE, or SOS features.

Are third-party straps safe for sensitive skin?

Products that come into contact with the skin are subject to EU regulations regarding nickel release. Choose a strap where the manufacturer clearly specifies the material, and try silicone, nylon, or fabric if you have a reaction to metal.



Check out these products

1 of 4